Fresh Hand-Tossed Pizzas, Salads, Wings & Beer/Wine To-Go in Quarryville, PA!
Sam's New York Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant 2 E State St
2 E State St, Quarryville, PA
Pickup Only
Appetizers
Breaded Mushrooms
Golden fried mushrooms with marinara.$8.50Broccoli Cheddar Bites
Crispy battered broccoli & cheddar with ranch.$9.00Cacio Di Pepe Pasta Balls
Crispy panko-crusted pasta balls filled with a classic blend of cracked black pepper and Pecorino Romano cheese, fried to golden perfection and served with our homemade tomato sauce for dipping. A unique Italian-inspired appetizer packed with bold flavor in every bite.$12.95Calamari Fritti
Lightly fried crispy calamari tossed with crisp banana peppers & marinara.$14.95Chicken Tenders
Panko breaded chicken tenders with choice of sauce.$9.95Garlic Bread
Our homemade bread is topped with a savory garlic butter spread and baked fresh until golden brown. A classic favorite with the perfect blend of buttery flavor and garlic goodness.Garlic Knots
Warm homemade knots tossed in garlic butter. Served with marinara.$7.00Jalapeño Poppers
Cheddar-stuffed jalapeños with ranch.$8.95Korean Pork Bites
Crispy pork belly in sweet & spicy Gochujang sauce with sesame.$12.95Meatballs
Homemade meatballs in marinara.$8.95Mozzarella Sticks
Crispy battered mozzarella with marinara.$8.95Onion Rings
Crispy panko-breaded rings with ranch.$9.95Soup of the Day
ask your server for selection$5.99
Fries
French Fries
Crispy golden fries cooked to perfection and lightly seasoned for the perfect side to complete any meal.$5.00Seasoned Wedges
Thick-cut potato wedges coated in a flavorful seasoned crust for a crispy, crunchy bite on the outside with a warm, fluffy potato center. The perfect hearty side for any meal.$6.00Old Bay Fries
Crispy fries tossed in Old Bay seasoning with melted American.$6.50Messy Fries
Loaded with bacon, cheddar & mozzarella cheese. Served with ranch.$12.95
Salads
Antipasto Salad
Iceberg lettuce topped with tomatoes, red onions, carrots, sliced ham, salami, capicola & provolone, dressed with sweet peppers & banana peppers.$15.95Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, parmesan, black pepper & garlic knot.$11.95Chef Salad
Iceberg lettuce loaded with tomatoes, red onions, carrots, ham & turkey.$14.95Chicken Salad
Crisp iceberg lettuce with tomatoes, red onions & carrots.$14.95Chicken Bacon Avocado Salad
Romaine lettuce with grilled chicken, sliced avocado, tomatoes & crisp bacon.$15.95Garden Salad
Crisp iceberg lettuce with tomatoes, red onions & carrots.$11.95Dinner Salad
$7.95Taco Salad
Seasoned beef or chicken, lettuce, tomatoes & cheddar cheese inside a crisp tortilla bowl.$14.95
Cold Sub
Cold Subs - Medium
American Sub - Medium 8"
Ham, American cheese & salami, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & choice of mayo or oil & vinegar.$9.95Ham & Cheese Sub - Medium 8"
Fresh sliced ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & choice of mayo or oil & vinegar.$8.95Italian Sub - Medium 8"
Sam's Italian sub made with freshly sliced ham, Genoa salami, Italian capicola & provolone.$10.95Tuna & Cheese Sub - Medium 8"
Tuna, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & choice of mayo or oil & vinegar.$9.95Turkey & Cheese Sub - Medium 8"
Oven-roasted turkey & provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & choice of mayo or oil & vinegar.$9.95
Cold Subs - Large
American Sub - Large 16"
Ham, American cheese & salami, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & choice of mayo or oil & vinegar.$13.95Ham & Cheese Sub - Large 16"
Fresh sliced ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & choice of mayo or oil & vinegar.$12.95Italian Sub - Large 16"
Sam's Italian sub made with freshly sliced ham, Genoa salami, Italian capicola & provolone.$16.95Tuna & Cheese Sub - Large 16"
Tuna, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & choice of mayo or oil & vinegar.$14.95Turkey & Cheese Sub - Large 16"
Oven-roasted turkey & provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & choice of mayo or oil & vinegar.$14.95
Hot Subs
Hot Subs - Medium
Cheeseburger Sub - Medium 8"
Grilled burger with American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.$13.95Chicken Parmigiana Sub - Medium 8"
Crispy chicken topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella, then baked to a crisp.$10.95Meatball Sub - Medium 8"
Meatballs in sauce with mozzarella.$11.95Chopped Cheese - Medium 8"
true New York classic featuring seasoned ground beef chopped together with fried onions and loaded with melted American cheese. Served hot and packed with bold flavor on a fresh roll for the ultimate NYC-style sandwich experience.$12.95
Steak Subs
Steak Subs - Medium
Buffalo Chicken Steak Sub - Medium 8"
Chicken, fried onions, American cheese & Sam's Buffalo sauce.$10.95California Sub - Medium 8"
Traditional grilled sliced steak with sauteed onions, melted American, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo.$12.95Cheesesteak Sub - Medium 8"
Traditional grilled sliced steak with sauteed onions, melted American cheese & sauce.$11.95Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Steak Sub - Medium 8"
Chicken, bacon, American cheese & ranch.$13.95Philadelphia Sub - Medium 8"
Grilled steak with onions, peppers & cheddar.$13.95Pizzaiola Sub - Medium 8"
Traditional grilled sliced steak with sauteed onions, topped with mozzarella then toasted in the oven until crispy.$13.95Special Sub - Medium 8"
Steak with onions, peppers, mushrooms, American cheese & sauce.$13.95
Steak Subs - Large
Buffalo Chicken Steak Sub - Large 16"
Chicken, fried onions, American cheese & Sam's Buffalo sauce.$14.95California Sub - Large 16"
Traditional grilled sliced steak with sauteed onions, melted American, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo.$17.95Cheesesteak Sub - Large 16"
Traditional grilled sliced steak with sauteed onions, melted American cheese & sauce.$15.95Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Steak Sub - Large 16"
Chicken, bacon, American cheese & ranch.$17.95Philadelphia Sub - Large 16"
Grilled steak with onions, peppers & cheddar.$17.95Pizzaiola Sub - Large 16"
Traditional grilled sliced steak with sauteed onions, topped with mozzarella then toasted in the oven until crispy.$17.95Special Sub - Large 16"
Steak with onions, peppers, mushrooms, American cheese & sauce.$17.95
Italian Dishes
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded chicken topped with marinara & melted mozzarella.$19.95Fettuccine Alfredo
Fettuccine in creamy Alfredo sauce.$17.95Create A Pasta
Choose your pasta, sauce, and optional toppings.$18.95Lasagna
Layered with ricotta, ground beef & mozzarella, baked bubbly.$19.95Stuffed Shells
Ricotta-stuffed shells with sauce & mozzarella.$17.95Four Cheese Gnocci
Pillowy potato gnocchi stuffed with a delicious blend of four cheeses, tossed in our homemade tomato sauce and topped with melted mozzarella cheese. A rich and comforting Italian favorite that’s perfect as a shareable appetizer or a satisfying entrée for one.$14.95
Handhelds
Handhelds
Double Smashed Burger
Two smashed patties, American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & house sauce.$14.95Mushroom Burger
Charbroiled burger topped with mushrooms & provolone.$14.95Bacon Burger
Charbroiled burger topped with lots of crisp bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & cheddar cheese.$15.95Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomatoes & onions.$14.95Backyard Burger
Grilled burger with American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo.$14.95Cajun Chicken Sandwich
Cajun seasoned chicken breast, lettuce, tomatoes & onions topped with American cheese.$14.95Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
Panko breaded chicken tossed in Nashville hot sauce with pickles.$14.95Chicken & Cheese Quesadilla
Chicken & cheese quesadilla served with our homemade salsa & sour cream.$15.95Chicken Avocado Sandwich
Grilled chicken, avocado, lettuce, tomatoes & citrus chipotle sauce.$15.95Chopped Cheese
Grilled burger chopped with onions & melted American cheese. A melty New York-style classic.$12.95Chicken Fiesta
Crispy chicken, creamy ranch, fresh lettuce, and ripe tomatoes served in an open-faced wrap, then toasted until golden and crispy for the perfect crunch in every bite.$10.95Nashville Hot COD Sandwich
Our crispy panko-breaded cod is piled onto a fresh homemade roll and finished with a zesty Nashville hot tartar sauce, crisp lettuce, and fresh tomatoes. Spicy, crunchy, and packed with flavor—served with a side of golden$15.95
Panini
Chicken Cordon Bleu Panini
Grilled chicken, ham & provolone with honey mustard.$14.95Cheesesteak Panini
Sliced steak, fried onions & provolone with sauce.$14.95Patty Melt Panini
Burger with grilled onions, American cheese & Thousand Island.$14.95Chicken Pesto Panini
Grilled chicken, mozzarella & pesto.$14.95Mojo Pork Cuban Panini
Slow-roasted mojo-seasoned pork layered with savory ham, melted Swiss cheese, thick-cut pickle chips, and tangy mustard, then pressed to perfection on a toasted panini. Served with a side of golden fries.$14.95
Wraps
BBQ Chicken Crunch Wrap
Crispy Chicken, red onions, lettuce, cheddar cheese, ranch & BBQ sauce.$14.95Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy chicken, lettuce & Buffalo sauce.$14.95Cheesesteak Wrap
Sliced grilled chicken or steak, fried onions & melted provolone. Served with a side of sauce.$14.95Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce & Caesar dressing.$14.95Chicken Ranch Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, mozzarella & ranch.$14.95Chipotle Chicken Wrap
Crispy chicken, lettuce, chipotle sauce & ranch.$14.95Taco Wrap
Choice of seasoned chicken or beef, lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar cheese & ranch.$14.95Turkey Bacon Ranch Wrap
Sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce & ranch.$14.95
Pizza Menu
Pizza Personal 10"
Cheese Pizza - Personal 10"
Classic cheese with Sam's signature sauce.$12.00Veggie-Licious Pizza - Personal 10"
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives & spinach.$15.00White Pizza - Personal 10"
Always a classic - garlic butter, ricotta cheese & mozzarella, no sauce.$14.00Sam's Special Pizza - Personal 10"
Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, green peppers, onions & mushrooms.$15.00Hawaiian Pizza - Personal 10"
Ham, pineapple & mozzarella.$14.00Three Cheese Pizza - Personal 10"
Mozzarella, provolone & parmesan.$14.00Meat Lover's Pizza - Personal 10"
Ooh heavenly meats! Sausage, hamburger, ham, bacon & of course, pepperoni.$15.00
Pizza Medium 14"
Cheese Pizza - Medium 14"
Classic cheese with Sam's signature sauce.$14.00Veggie-Licious Pizza - Medium 14"
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives & spinach.$18.00White Pizza - Medium 14"
Always a classic - garlic butter, ricotta cheese & mozzarella, no sauce.$16.00Hawaiian Pizza - Medium 14"
Ham, pineapple & mozzarella.$18.00Sam's Special Pizza - Medium 14"
Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, green peppers, onions & mushrooms.$20.00Three Cheese Pizza - Medium 14"
Mozzarella, provolone & parmesan.$18.00Meat Lover's Pizza - Medium 14"
Ooh heavenly meats! Sausage, hamburger, ham, bacon & of course, pepperoni.$18.00
Pizza Large 16"
Cheese Pizza - Large 16"
Classic cheese with Sam's signature sauce.$16.00Veggie-Licious Pizza - Large 16"
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives & spinach.$22.00White Pizza - Large 16"
Always a classic - garlic butter, ricotta cheese & mozzarella, no sauce.$18.00Hawaiian Pizza - Large 16"
Ham, pineapple & mozzarella.$20.50Sam's Special Pizza - Large 16"
Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, green peppers, onions & mushrooms.$26.00Three Cheese Pizza - Large 16"
Mozzarella, provolone & parmesan.$24.00Meat Lover's Pizza - Large 16"
Ooh heavenly meats! Sausage, hamburger, ham, bacon & of course, pepperoni.$26.00
Sicilian 16x16
Cheese Pizza - Sicilian 16x16"
Classic cheese with Sam's signature sauce.$20.00Veggie-Licious Pizza - Sicilian 16x16"
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives & spinach.$28.00Hawaiian Pizza - Sicilian 16x16"
Ham, pineapple & mozzarella.$25.00Sam's Special Pizza - Sicilian 16x16"
Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, green peppers, onions & mushrooms.$30.00Three Cheese Pizza - Sicilian 16x16"
Mozzarella, provolone & parmesan.$26.00Meat Lover's Pizza - Sicilian 16x16"
Ooh heavenly meats! Sausage, hamburger, ham, bacon & of course, pepperoni.$30.00
Gourmet Pizza
Gourmet Pizza 10"
BBQ Chicken Gourmet Pizza - Personal 10"
Grilled chicken & BBQ sauce.$14.00Buffalo Chicken Gourmet Pizza - Personal 10"
It's getting hot in here! Crispy chicken drizzled with our homemade Sam's Buffalo sauce.$15.00Chicken Bacon Ranch Gourmet Pizza - Personal 10"
Grilled chicken topped with crispy bacon & finished off with some creamy ranch dressing.$15.00Dill-Ightful Pickle Pie - Personal 10"
Garlic butter, crisp pickle chips, ranch & parmesan cheese.$15.00Margherita Gourmet Pizza - Personal 10"
Fresh tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella & basil.$13.00Philly Cheesesteak Gourmet Pizza - Personal 10"
Sliced steak topped with mozzarella, American & cheddar.$14.00Taco Gourmet Pizza - Personal 10"
Seasoned beef or chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar & ranch.$16.00
Gourmet Pizza 16"
BBQ Chicken Gourmet Pizza - Large 16"
Grilled chicken & BBQ sauce.$22.00Buffalo Chicken Gourmet Pizza - Large 16"
It's getting hot in here! Crispy chicken drizzled with our homemade Sam's Buffalo sauce.$26.00Chicken Bacon Ranch Gourmet Pizza - Large 16"
Grilled chicken topped with crispy bacon & finished off with some creamy ranch dressing.$26.00Dill-Ightful Pickle Pie - Large 16"
Garlic butter, crisp pickle chips, ranch & parmesan cheese.$24.00Margherita Gourmet Pizza - Large 16"
Fresh tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella & basil.$17.00Philly Cheesesteak Gourmet Pizza - Large 16"
Sliced steak topped with mozzarella, American & cheddar.$26.00Taco Gourmet Pizza - Large 16"
Seasoned beef or chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar & ranch.$26.00
Boli's
Small Stromboli & Calzones
Traditional Stromboli - Small
Ham, salami, sausage, mozzarella & sauce.$13.00Cheesesteak Stromboli - Small
Sliced steak with fried onions, mozzarella & sauce. Our bestselling stromboli -- loaded & delicious!$14.00Calzone - Small
Mozzarella, ricotta & ham (no sauce).$12.00Special Stromboli - Small
Ham, salami, sausage, mushrooms, onions, hamburger, pepperoni, mozzarella & sauce.$15.00Buffalo Chicken Stromboli - Small
Sliced chicken in Sam's Buffalo sauce with mozzarella.$15.00Create A Boli - Small
Build your perfect stromboli just the way you like it! Every stromboli starts with our signature pizza sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, then customize it with up to three of your favorite toppings. Baked until golden brown and served fresh from the oven.$13.00Veggie Stromboli - Small
A delicious blend of fresh mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, onions, and green peppers layered with our signature pizza sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, all wrapped in our fresh dough and baked to a golden brown.$15.00
Medium Stromboli & Calzones
Traditional Stromboli - Medium
Ham, salami, sausage, mozzarella & sauce.$17.00Cheesesteak Stromboli - Medium
Sliced steak with fried onions, mozzarella & sauce. Our bestselling stromboli -- loaded & delicious!$20.00Calzone - Medium
Mozzarella, ricotta & ham (no sauce).$16.00Special Stromboli - Medium
Ham, salami, sausage, mushrooms, onions, hamburger, pepperoni, mozzarella & sauce.$20.00Buffalo Chicken Stromboli - Medium
Sliced chicken in Sam's Buffalo sauce with mozzarella.$18.00Create A Boli - Medium
Build your perfect stromboli just the way you like it! Every stromboli starts with our signature pizza sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, then customize it with up to three of your favorite toppings. Baked until golden brown and served fresh from the oven.$17.00Veggie Stromboli - Medium
A delicious blend of fresh mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, onions, and green peppers layered with our signature pizza sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, all wrapped in our fresh dough and baked to a golden brown.$20.00
Large Stromboli & Calzones
Traditional Stromboli - Large
Ham, salami, sausage, mozzarella & sauce.$21.00Cheesesteak Stromboli - Large
Sliced steak with fried onions, mozzarella & sauce. Our bestselling stromboli -- loaded & delicious!$28.00Calzone - Large
Mozzarella, ricotta & ham (no sauce).$21.00Special Stromboli - Large
Ham, salami, sausage, mushrooms, onions, hamburger, pepperoni, mozzarella & sauce.$26.00Buffalo Chicken Stromboli - Large
Sliced chicken in Sam's Buffalo sauce with mozzarella.$26.00Create A Boli - Large
Build your perfect stromboli just the way you like it! Every stromboli starts with our signature pizza sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, then customize it with up to three of your favorite toppings. Baked until golden brown and served fresh from the oven.$21.00Veggie Stromboli - Large
A delicious blend of fresh mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, onions, and green peppers layered with our signature pizza sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, all wrapped in our fresh dough and baked to a golden brown.$26.00
Desserts
Tiramisu
Ladyfingers soaked in coffee liqueur, filled & topped with a sweet cream mascarpone.$7.95Zeppole
Fried Italian doughnut holes tossed with cinnamon sugar & served with chocolate sauce.$9.95Chocolate Peanut Butter Dream
Chocolate crust stacked with creamy peanut butter mousse, rich ganache & crushed peanut butter cups.$8.95Cannoli
A large pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese & chocolate chips.$6.95Key Lime Pie
Key lime creme with graham cracker crust mini baked pie.$7.95
Take Out Soda
Pepsi Take Out Products

2 Liter Pepsi
$4.492 Liter Mountain Dew
$4.492 Liter Mug Rootbeer
$4.492 Liter Dr. Pepper
$4.492 Liter Pepsi Zero
$4.492 Liter Starry
$4.49Tropicana Apple Juice
$3.49Celcsius Apple Pear
$3.99Starbuck Mocha
$4.99Pure Leaf Extra Sweet
$3.99Pure Leaf Lemon
$3.99Pure Leaf Peach
$3.99Aquafina
$2.49Crush Orange
$2.99Dole Lemonade
$2.99Dole Strawberry Lemonade
$2.99Dr. Pepper
$2.99Gatorade Fruit Punch
$3.49Gatorade Glacier Freeze
$3.49Mountain Dew
$2.99Mug Rootbeer
$2.99
Pepsi
$2.99Pepsi Wild Cherry
$2.99Pepsi Zero
$2.99Schweppes Ginger Ale
$2.99Starry
$2.99
Catering
Catering Items
Garden Salad
$24.99Garden w/ Chicken
$49.99Caesar Salad
$29.99Antipasto
$54.99Penne w/ Tomato
$49.00Baked Ziti
$59.99Chicken Parm
$89.99Lasagna
$59.99Veggie Lasagna
$59.99Stuffed Shells
$59.99Chicken Alfredo
$89.99Meatballs
$59.99Sausage, Peppers & Onions
$54.99Chicken Tenders & Fries
$59.9950 Bone-In Wings
$59.9950 Boneless Wings
$64.99Garlic Knots
$19.99Cannoli Tray
$44.99Tiramisu Tray
$49.99
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$14.95
Crispy chicken, lettuce & Buffalo sauce.
Customize your item
Wrap Instructions
Select up to 1
Hand Held Add
Optional
Remove Ingredients - Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Select up to 2
Buffalo Chicken Wrap Extras
Optional
Handheld Upgrades
Select up to 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1